Are Birkenstocks Really Good for All Feet? A Podiatrist's Review

You've heard the hype. Birkenstocks are the "it" shoe for comfort and support, supposedly good for everything from plantar fasciitis to bunions. But is it true? Can one shoe really be the answer to everyone's foot problems?

Let's face it: feet are complicated. Each person's foot is unique, with its own shape, structure, and potential issues. What works wonders for one person might actually worsen another person's pain. So, before you jump on the Birkenstock bandwagon, you should understand the truth behind the claims.

Below, we'll explore the pros and cons of Birkenstocks from a podiatrist's expert perspective. We'll also discuss who might benefit (and who might not!) and how to make informed choices for your foot health.

» Make your Birkenstocks work better for YOU with custom orthotics

What Are Birkenstocks?

Birkenstocks have a long history, dating back to 1774 in Germany. They were first widely sold in Europe in 1925 and arrived in America in 1966. Known for their comfortable design and supportive footbeds, Birkenstocks have only grown in popularity.

Here's why:

• Anatomically Shaped Footbed: Contoured cork-latex conforms to your foot, promoting proper alignment and enhanced comfort.
• Adjustable Straps: Customizable fit accommodates various foot shapes, preventing pressure points.
• Durability: Built to last with tough materials like cork, latex, and rubber.
• Sustainable Materials: Made with natural, renewable cork and leather for a comfortable and eco-conscious choice.

» Think Birkenstocks aren't the perfect fit? Find out if Crocs are any better

8 Conditions Birkenstocks Are Good For

1. Flat Feet

Flat feet occur when the foot's arch collapses, causing misalignment in the foot and lower leg. Birkenstocks' built-in arch support helps lift and support the arch, reducing discomfort and improving alignment. This support also redistributes weight, lessens strain on the arch, and reduces pain. Also, the deep heel cup enhances foot and ankle stability.

For those with severe flat feet, Birkenstocks might initially feel uncomfortable or lack sufficient arch support. In these cases, you can combine them with low-profile custom orthotics for optimal comfort and support.

2. High Arches

While Birkenstocks have built-in arch support and a deep heel cup, these features may not be enough for those with very high arches. The cork-latex material, however, does provide cushioning and support, helping to distribute weight and reduce strain on the arch.

Overall, they are a good option for people with high arches, but those with very high arches may need extra support.

3. Achilles Tendonitis

Achilles tendonitis is often caused by strain or overuse. Birkenstocks promote healthy foot and ankle movement, which can reduce strain on the Achilles tendon. The arch support and deep heel cup encourage a natural walking pattern, protecting the tendon.

The cork-latex footbed absorbs shock, further reducing strain on the tendon. The slightly raised heel also lessens the stretch on the Achilles tendon, easing inflammation and pain.

While Birkenstocks can provide relief for mild to moderate Achilles tendonitis, they may not be enough for severe cases.

» Discover the worst shoes for Achilles tendonitis

4. Hammer Toes

Hammer toe is often caused by narrow shoes that squeeze the toes or shoes that lack arch support. Age and conditions like diabetes can also contribute to hammer toe.

Birkenstocks have a wide, open-toe design that gives your toes plenty of space to spread out naturally. This reduces pressure and strain on the toes, which can help with hammer toe symptoms. The open design also prevents rubbing and friction, which can cause calluses and blisters.

» Learn about the "super shoes" taking the running world by storm

5. Metatarsalgia

Several factors, including poor arch support, narrow shoes, and high-impact activities, can cause Metatarsalgia. Birkenstocks have a built-in metatarsal support bar and arch support that help reduce strain and keep the toes properly aligned. The cork-latex material also absorbs shock and promotes natural foot movement.

These features work together to reduce pressure on the forefoot, which can help alleviate metatarsalgia symptoms.

6. Bunions

Bunions are often caused by narrow shoes, high heels, and repetitive stress on the joint. Birkenstocks offer several features that can help:

• Wide Toe Box: This reduces pressure on the bunion, alleviating pain and preventing it from worsening.
• Arch Support and Heel Cup: These promote healthy foot movement and reduce strain on the affected joint.
• Adjustable Straps: These allow for a comfortable and secure fit, further minimizing pressure on the bunion.

Birkenstocks can help improve bunion symptoms and prevent the condition from getting worse by reducing strain and promoting proper foot alignment.

» Find out how to prevent bunions and keep them from worsening

7. Overpronation

The shoe's design features an anatomical footbed, deep heel cup, and arch support, all of which help reduce overpronation. These features work similarly to how they help with flat feet, providing support and stability.

Birkenstocks alone may not be enough for severe overpronation. You might need custom orthotics for additional support. But they are a good option for mild to moderate cases.

» Birkenstocks aren't enough? Pair them with overpronation orthotics

8. Plantar Fasciitis

Plantar fasciitis is often caused by a lack of arch support, which puts stress on the plantar fascia—the tissue that connects your heel to your toes. Birkenstocks' arch support helps relieve this strain and reduce pain. Redistributing pressure protects the plantar fascia from excessive stress. The deep heel cup also adds stability and support, further reducing strain.

For severe cases, Birkenstocks might not be enough to alleviate all symptoms. Individually-designed orthotics can provide extra support and pain relief when worn with the shoes. Overall, Birkenstocks are a suitable choice for mild plantar fasciitis but may not be sufficient for severe cases.

You Might Not Benefit From Birkenstocks if You Have These Conditions

As mentioned, in some severe cases of foot conditions or shapes, Birkenstocks may not be effective in managing associated symptoms for:

Severe Overpronation

The built-in arch support might not be sufficient to prevent the ankle from rolling inward. In these cases, you may need shoes with a more rigid sole or custom orthotics to control the inward motion and to avoid strain on your feet and ankles.

Severe Flat Feet

While Birkenstocks can help with mild flat feet, they may not provide enough support for severe cases. If you have severe flat feet, you might need more specialized shoes or custom orthotics to support your arches and prevent foot fatigue and pain properly.

Severe Cases of Foot Deformity

If you have a significant deformity, Birkenstocks might be uncomfortable and could even worsen your pain. In these situations, specialized footwear or custom orthotics are often necessary to provide proper support and manage the condition effectively.

It's important to prevent these conditions from worsening, and sometimes Birkenstocks alone may not offer enough support to do that.

» Discover the signs that indicate you should see a podiatrist

What to Consider When Buying Birkenstocks

• Lifestyle: Think about how you'll use your Birkenstocks. They're great for everyday wear, especially if you spend a lot of time on your feet or walk long distances. But, they may not be the best choice for high-impact activities like running or sports. For those activities, consider shoes with more cushioning and shock absorption.
• Climate: Birkenstocks are not ideal for wet or humid weather. The materials can absorb water and may deteriorate over time. If you need a water-resistant option, consider the synthetic EVA collection.
• Foot Width: Birkenstocks are generally best for people with medium to wide feet. If you have narrow feet, they might feel loose even with the straps adjusted. In this case, you can explore other Birkenstock styles that might offer a better fit.

» Do your feet roll outward when you run? Find relief with supination shoes

The Final Verdict on Birkenstocks

The key takeaway? Feet are as individual as the people they belong to. While Birkenstocks offer numerous benefits, it's crucial to listen to your feet. Pay attention to how they feel, consult a podiatrist when needed, and prioritize finding footwear that truly supports your unique needs.

Already love your Birkenstocks but wish they offered a bit more personalized support? Upstep has the solution! Our custom orthotics are designed to enhance the comfort and alignment of your favorite sandals.

In just 5 minutes, you can complete our online quiz and get matched with orthotics tailored to your unique foot shape and needs.